Neutral or Selective? How Schools Handle the US Flag and Speech
A few Septembers ago, I walked into a high school before first period and paused in the doorway. Two dozen teenagers stood to recite the Pledge. One kid kept his hands in his hoodie pocket and stared at the floor. Another wore a small flag pin near his collar, the clasp crooked. In the back row, a student sat, lips still, looking toward a rainbow flag sticker on a laptop. The teacher, a veteran with a calm voice, led the room, then moved on to a quiz as if nothing unusual h
Should Schools Mirror the Community—or Redefine It? The Flag Question
Walk into a school lobby and you can read the room before anyone speaks. A flag in the corner, a poster on the wall, the morning announcements, the student projects along the hallway, all of it signals what the adults believe school is for. Some communities want those signals to feel familiar, even patriotic. Others want the space to feel deliberately open and less anchored to national symbols. The debate over flags is really a debate about purpose. Should schools reflect c
Gatekeeping the Red, White, and Blue: Should Parents Have More Control Over What Their Children Are Exposed to in School?
A few years ago I sat in a crowded cafeteria for a curriculum night that felt more like a town hall. On one side, parents worried about a new social studies unit they thought leaned too hard into guilt and grievance. On the other, teachers who had spent months designing lessons to help students analyze primary sources and wrestle with the complexity of our country. Everyone cared about kids learning the truth. They disagreed on method and emphasis. The hum in the room was n
For Freedom and Pride: Celebrating America by Flying the Flag
A flag on a breeze is a simple thing. Cloth, color, a bit of stitching. Yet every time I hoist the Stars and Stripes, I feel the tug of something larger, an electric thread that runs from Lexington green to a stadium tunnel where a parent in uniform surprises a child. I have raised a flag in the soft light before dawn and taken it down by headlamp as a thunderstorm pushed in from the west. Each time reminds me that this ritual is not just about fabric or a pole. It is about
Tradition Under the Banner: Are American Flag Rituals Preserved in Schools—or Phased Out?
Around 8:05 a.m., the hallway outside a middle school cafeteria sounds like a soft orchestra of chairs sliding and zippers closing. The intercom crackles, students rise, some place hands on hearts, a few stand with arms at their sides, a handful keep their seats. The Pledge of Allegiance still happens in many American schools, but the scene no longer looks uniform. In one classroom, the pledge is daily and dutiful. In another, it is optional and quiet. In a third, it is gon